About Amy

Amy Costello

Amy Costello
"The Facilitator"


While attending college at FGCU, Amy worked as a lifeguard at the Sanibel Recreation Center which is where her love of Sanibel and the island lifestyle began. After graduating, she began her career in the hospitality industry at an island rental company. Her professional interests eventually changed into Real Estate and she began working with Phaidra McDermott in 2007. Amy has assisted with approximately 287 transactions, over $378 Million in sales and now has over a decade of experience.

Amy's entrepreneurial spirit emerged when she and her husband decided to take their hobby of home brewing professional and opened Point Ybel Brewing Company. While "giving new meaning to Island Hopping", their brewery has earned multiple local and state wide awards over the years.

As a mother of 2 children, Amy enjoys spending time at the beach, boating, and biking around the islands with her family. She is a firm believer in the mindset "you can accomplish anything you put your mind to" using hard work and dedication. Her experiences as a mother, a successful business owner, and a longtime assistant to a top producer give Amy a comprehensive perspective when helping clients realize their goals of owning or selling real estate on Sanibel and Captiva Islands. If you are looking for a realtor with a warm yet dedicated and mindful disposition, contact Amy for your island real estate needs.

Amy's Listings

Found 2 Properties
11318 Lake Cypress LOOP
For Sale

11318 Lake Cypress LOOP

Price: $305,000
City: Fort Myers
MLS #: 218029156
Community: GATEWAY
Sq Feet: 3256
Type: Single Family
Bedroom(s): 5
Bathroom(s): 3
16381 Kelly Woods DR
For Sale

16381 Kelly Woods DR

Price: $199,999
City: Fort Myers
MLS #: 218027617
Sq Feet: 1336
Type: Condo\Town Home
Bedroom(s): 2
Bathroom(s): 2

Subscribe to Our Property Updates

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest Sanibel and Captiva market update!

About Us

Kingfisher Real Estate Logo

Contact Info

Kingfisher Real Estate Inc.
2402 Palm Ridge Road Suites 1,2 & 3
Sanibel Island Florida 33957

Phone: 239-472-4411

Have a question?

© 2018 All rights reserved.